There's much hate toward people that were/are Jewish. I don't use the term, "the Jews", nor the Jewish people, because these collectives are not existential, they are instrumentalized to further hate.
That's quite a compilation, Librarian! On the timeline, I was wondering if there's non-scriptural sources for any of those dates and events? I'm curious also as to the word that 'Jew' is substituting for on the expulsion list since Jew with the modern spelling wasn't used until the 18th c. according to the OED. It's just something I've been trying to track, what historical sources say and what the original words are that are used. This has some of my research so far, thanks much: https://thirdparadigm.substack.com/p/what-is-a-jew
I did visit your site from the invitation link you offered, and as you know I have commented here and there. It is impressive work that you do. (A lot more than I want to get into!).
I might have said before, that I don't know who compiled this expulsion list, nor for what purpose. I picked it up several years ago, (maybe because it was such a weird file, so very long for a graphic). And it had been on my desktop ever since, with no thought to use it.
So I don't even have the original source, and I don't know why they used the word "Jew".
Thank you, Librarian, I realized since I didn't respond to your comments in order, that you'd answered my question there. Interesting that your sources show the Exodus and conquering of Canaan to have never happened, at least in the timeframe given. Nefahotep, who comments on my site, has been tracing this back to the expulsion of the Heksos, who were foreign rulers in Egypt, not slaves. I would be curious to research this list from the other side and find out what was happening in these countries just prior to the expulsion of this group of people that are named as Jews in this document. I'll link it in a future episode and see if anyone has more clues. For me, I'm looking for an underlying strategy that these people were likely unwitting participants in.
I appreciate your compliment on my work and appreciate that it's more than you want to get into! I'm glad for the attention you've given it, with all the work that you do.
Yes it would be great to know details that led up to so many expulsions. One detail is the term JEWS, that lumps everyone together into one guilty mass. It is said that Jewish people got themselves into the role of tax-collectors in many instances. That was hated. Rabbis believed the Jewish are special, hence all others are inferior and treated such, if they are not the powerful. Jewish might not intermix, and stay isolated, as a myth in our midst. Who knows what you can do with that myth. If Jewish were able to control business, local wealthy might want to get them out of there. (For sure.)
In the latter example it may have been no different than now, the local elite built a (false) case against their business competitors, and brainwashed the populous to buy into it. (There were other factors too.) When the Jewish were ousted, the businesses went to the locals. I believe in this last one as a factor.
Outwardly it is simple, that your stereotypes of behavior don't match my stereotypes of behavior, enough that I reject yours as alien. Zionism totally rejects any notion that they could look inward to find their part in the confrontation. What you said, an underlying strategy that these people were likely unwitting participants in. Now it is only about being the biggest victim in the world. I see that as a losing proposition. So far, they have been able to force that view on the world.
The first question is who compiled the list of expulsions and chose to use the term 'Jews' even centuries and millennia before it was coined. Was the list compiled by someone looking to impose guilt on this group? From reading it, I don't think that could be true. In every case, it only shows what was done TO some group the author labels as Jews, not BY them. So the author is looking to show a trend of the guilt of the rest of the world, really, and the innocent victimization of 'Jews,' not lump them into a guilty mass. It's proving the base premise of Zionism that the Jews cannot possibly assimilate into any other land, like any other religion or ethnicity, because other people are hate-full and reject them.
My book looks at coinage and tax collection as the means by which people were co-opted into the conquest and enslavement of their neighbors. It's the beginning of the cognitive dissonance that we are good people, and yet to protect our own families, we participate in a system that destroys other families. The Kennites may have been the clan represented as Cain, who were metalworkers and 'protected' while they infiltrated other societies to work for the lords. They would certainly have been hated if they were turning all the sovereign people into servants of that lord through taxation in his 'coin of the realm.'
Yahweh not only tolerates genocide but requires it, down to the suckling babe. But Yahweh never tolerates intermarriage. So the primary precept of Yahwism is blood purity and either subjugation of all others or their annihilation. That's an immoral religion.
I mentioned the Kol Nidre but I don't know if you're familiar with it. It's a prayer on the Day of Atonement in which the Jew is forgiven for breaking any oath in advance for the next year. In the early years of the US, ethnographers write about the difficulty of maintaining any judicial system when the Russian Jewish immigrants freely lied under oath. The practice of deception without and secrecy within is a precept of the religion. Jews themselves tried to get rid of it, but the theocracy wouldn't allow it.
So it's not merely a matter of being successful. It's success through a shared and authorized practice of deception and that whatever is done to benefit the group, no matter at who's expense, is blessed by god. That is, by its nature, sociopathic. No society or honest business can possibly co-exist with that belief system held by a subset.
And then you add to that the monetary system that controls all labor in the world being issued by the same group. And control of communication through the media. And an int'l group with that power who's backing any of their members against any country, even if they're only 1% of the population as was true for Germany. How does a society deal with that? I'm asking as an honest question because I can't see an answer to it.
Interesting going through the 2000 year of Jewish expulsions, I see many instances throughout time where Jews were repeatedly removed from Jerusalem. It suggests they left and suddenly reappeared, or maybe they were never completely expelled, only a select (from the listings you two provide above) group.
I also see expulsions listed on the chart from Arab Countries where Jews practiced killing of young girls (firstborn sacrifice practiced??? unless it was a Son??).
Question remaining is when/how does this unsustainable system finally collapse? Been going on for almost 3 thousand years. When's enough, enough??
That's quite a compilation, Librarian! On the timeline, I was wondering if there's non-scriptural sources for any of those dates and events? I'm curious also as to the word that 'Jew' is substituting for on the expulsion list since Jew with the modern spelling wasn't used until the 18th c. according to the OED. It's just something I've been trying to track, what historical sources say and what the original words are that are used. This has some of my research so far, thanks much: https://thirdparadigm.substack.com/p/what-is-a-jew
I did visit your site from the invitation link you offered, and as you know I have commented here and there. It is impressive work that you do. (A lot more than I want to get into!).
I might have said before, that I don't know who compiled this expulsion list, nor for what purpose. I picked it up several years ago, (maybe because it was such a weird file, so very long for a graphic). And it had been on my desktop ever since, with no thought to use it.
So I don't even have the original source, and I don't know why they used the word "Jew".
.
Thank you, Librarian, I realized since I didn't respond to your comments in order, that you'd answered my question there. Interesting that your sources show the Exodus and conquering of Canaan to have never happened, at least in the timeframe given. Nefahotep, who comments on my site, has been tracing this back to the expulsion of the Heksos, who were foreign rulers in Egypt, not slaves. I would be curious to research this list from the other side and find out what was happening in these countries just prior to the expulsion of this group of people that are named as Jews in this document. I'll link it in a future episode and see if anyone has more clues. For me, I'm looking for an underlying strategy that these people were likely unwitting participants in.
I appreciate your compliment on my work and appreciate that it's more than you want to get into! I'm glad for the attention you've given it, with all the work that you do.
Yes it would be great to know details that led up to so many expulsions. One detail is the term JEWS, that lumps everyone together into one guilty mass. It is said that Jewish people got themselves into the role of tax-collectors in many instances. That was hated. Rabbis believed the Jewish are special, hence all others are inferior and treated such, if they are not the powerful. Jewish might not intermix, and stay isolated, as a myth in our midst. Who knows what you can do with that myth. If Jewish were able to control business, local wealthy might want to get them out of there. (For sure.)
In the latter example it may have been no different than now, the local elite built a (false) case against their business competitors, and brainwashed the populous to buy into it. (There were other factors too.) When the Jewish were ousted, the businesses went to the locals. I believe in this last one as a factor.
Outwardly it is simple, that your stereotypes of behavior don't match my stereotypes of behavior, enough that I reject yours as alien. Zionism totally rejects any notion that they could look inward to find their part in the confrontation. What you said, an underlying strategy that these people were likely unwitting participants in. Now it is only about being the biggest victim in the world. I see that as a losing proposition. So far, they have been able to force that view on the world.
.
The first question is who compiled the list of expulsions and chose to use the term 'Jews' even centuries and millennia before it was coined. Was the list compiled by someone looking to impose guilt on this group? From reading it, I don't think that could be true. In every case, it only shows what was done TO some group the author labels as Jews, not BY them. So the author is looking to show a trend of the guilt of the rest of the world, really, and the innocent victimization of 'Jews,' not lump them into a guilty mass. It's proving the base premise of Zionism that the Jews cannot possibly assimilate into any other land, like any other religion or ethnicity, because other people are hate-full and reject them.
My book looks at coinage and tax collection as the means by which people were co-opted into the conquest and enslavement of their neighbors. It's the beginning of the cognitive dissonance that we are good people, and yet to protect our own families, we participate in a system that destroys other families. The Kennites may have been the clan represented as Cain, who were metalworkers and 'protected' while they infiltrated other societies to work for the lords. They would certainly have been hated if they were turning all the sovereign people into servants of that lord through taxation in his 'coin of the realm.'
Yahweh not only tolerates genocide but requires it, down to the suckling babe. But Yahweh never tolerates intermarriage. So the primary precept of Yahwism is blood purity and either subjugation of all others or their annihilation. That's an immoral religion.
I mentioned the Kol Nidre but I don't know if you're familiar with it. It's a prayer on the Day of Atonement in which the Jew is forgiven for breaking any oath in advance for the next year. In the early years of the US, ethnographers write about the difficulty of maintaining any judicial system when the Russian Jewish immigrants freely lied under oath. The practice of deception without and secrecy within is a precept of the religion. Jews themselves tried to get rid of it, but the theocracy wouldn't allow it.
So it's not merely a matter of being successful. It's success through a shared and authorized practice of deception and that whatever is done to benefit the group, no matter at who's expense, is blessed by god. That is, by its nature, sociopathic. No society or honest business can possibly co-exist with that belief system held by a subset.
And then you add to that the monetary system that controls all labor in the world being issued by the same group. And control of communication through the media. And an int'l group with that power who's backing any of their members against any country, even if they're only 1% of the population as was true for Germany. How does a society deal with that? I'm asking as an honest question because I can't see an answer to it.
For you and Librarian.
Interesting going through the 2000 year of Jewish expulsions, I see many instances throughout time where Jews were repeatedly removed from Jerusalem. It suggests they left and suddenly reappeared, or maybe they were never completely expelled, only a select (from the listings you two provide above) group.
I also see expulsions listed on the chart from Arab Countries where Jews practiced killing of young girls (firstborn sacrifice practiced??? unless it was a Son??).
Question remaining is when/how does this unsustainable system finally collapse? Been going on for almost 3 thousand years. When's enough, enough??