Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Librarian's avatar

As an answer to Igz Navi: (Part two of two)

The sharp decrease in the percentage of Jews among employees of the NKVD in 1939 did not occur due to the fact that by this time, as S.L. Beria (son), writes in his book "My Father Beria" (Moscow 2002), "the top of the Party apparatus and the state were Russophiles, who did not trust the 'foreigners' and hated them. The memoirist included Molotov, Andreev, Malenkov, and Zhdanov in the group of "Russian chauvinists," whose orders were carried out by Yezhov and Yagoda. The memoirist's father also allegedly became a forced "Russophile. The information he gathered showed that "three-quarters of the investigators and leaders of counterintelligence were Jews. Fearing that their too active presence in the representative organs might cause a wave of anti-Semitism, he decided to replace them with Russians.

For in that period there were often accusations that the " " Jews were oppressing and destroying the Russian people." Statistics of the national composition of the repressed show that the bulk of them were indeed Russians. Thus, the "Russophilia" of L.P. Beria, expressed in a change in the national composition of NKVD leaders and investigators, is explained by his concern for the well-being of non-Russian people.

By the end of 1938 the struggle for the elimination of the "fifth column" decreased. On November 17, SNKSSR and CC of All-Union Communist Party (of Bolsheviks) adopted a resolution prohibiting "mass arrest and eviction operations" and condemning "violation of legality". On November 25 the People's Commissar of Internal Affairs was relieved of his post, and soon he was arrested on charges of conspiracy and Yezhov was shot.

Appointed on the same day as the new People's Commissar, L.P. Beria began his activities with amnesties.

Compared with the years of the Great Terror, the scale of repression was significantly reduced. In 1939, "for counterrevolutionary and state crimes" 2,552 people were sentenced to death (7 people per day), in 1940 - 1,649 people (4-5/ day), in 1941, including the war half-year - 8,001 (24 people per day).

But in 1939-1940, 837,000 people were rehabilitated and released from prison.

The scale of repressions in the ruling party itself can be judged by the dynamics of expulsions from the ranks of the VKP(b). Thus in 1937-1938 216,000 people were expelled from the Party. (not shot) Later on, the number of those expelled decreased. In 1939, 26,700 left the Party ranks against their will. At the same time in 1939-1940 164,800 were restored. It was later calculated that 17 (50% percent) of 34 Politburo members who were members in 1917-1939 were repressed. Repressed were 17 (50%); of the 27 members of the Secretariat of the Central Committee, 15 (55.5%); of the 64 members of the Orgbureau, 42 (66%); of the 71 members of the Central Committee, 49 (70%); of the 70 chairmen and deputy chairmen of the Sovnarkom of the USSR

In March 1939 Stalin announced figures, according to which 270,000 less Communists were represented at the 16th - 11th Party Congress than at the previous Congress in early 1934. In the period between Congresses "more than 500 thousand young Bolsheviks, Party and Party adherents, of whom 20 percent were women, were nominated for leadership positions in the state and Party lines." Assuming that the nominations were made mainly to replace repressed leaders (although no doubt nominees were also replacing newly opened vacancies), we can also conclude that the number of repressed Communists who had held leadership positions in the Party and State was about or slightly less than 500,000.

There seems to be some sense in the cited judgments of Molotov and Bukharin that purging the country on the eve of the war from potential opponents of the Soviet system and the existing regime of power was necessary. Otherwise, the scale of Hitler's pandering to "liberators of the USSR from the Stalinist regime", (the traitors to Russia), which the aggressors were counting on, would have been many times greater than it turned out to be in reality during the war.

But another thing is also obvious.

As a result of the repressions, which completed the "revolution from above", the personal power regime of Stalin, who was able to obey the social and economic realities, but also made extensive use of fear and violence along with other methods of ruling society, finally established itself in the country.

The regime established in the USSR at the end of the 1930s could not be effective without an authoritarian, cynical, and ruthless leader of the Stalinist type. The Red Army, especially its top commanding officers, suffered the most from repression. In the 1920's the army was formed by Trotsky, and was still loyal to him. From 837 persons who in 1935 had personal military ranks from colonel and above, 720 Trotskyite's (86%) were arrested. Totally, according to data of modern researchers in 1937-1938 37,000 officers were discharged from the Red Army, 29,000 of them for political reasons.

The Soviet Army, up to 8,000 officers were arrested and up to 5,000 shot. The number of those discharged was about 2.5 percent of the officer personnel on the eve of the war.

L. B. Mekhlis, who held the highest political position in the Red Army after the suicide of the head of the Red Army Political Department, Ya. B. Gamarnik, as well as Deputy People's Commissar of Defense for Personnel E. A. Shchadenko. According to the investigation's version the leadership of the conspiracy in the army after Tukhachevsky was unmasked and was executed by marshal A. I. Yegorov (since 1935 chief of the General Staff, since May 1937 first deputy People's Commissar of Defense of the USSR, in January 1938 he was appointed commander of the Transcaucasian Military District, in April of the same year he was arrested).

Then 1st rank commandant I. F. Fedko (in 1937 commanded the Kiev military district, since January 1938 he was first deputy People's Commissar of Defense, in July 1938 he was arrested).

Outstanding military figures of the USSR later almost unanimously noted the destructive role of repressions in the army in pre-war years. Marshal Zhukov believed that "Without 1937 there would have been no summer of 1941. Marshal I. S. Konev held the same position. "There is no doubt," he said, "that if there had been no thirty-seventh to thirty-eighth year, and not only in the army, but also in the party, in the country, we would have been incomparably stronger by the forty-first year than we were. "And I will say more," Marshal A. M. Vasilevsky argued. - Without the thirty-seventh year, perhaps there would have been no war at all in the forty-first year. (Only we would all be speaking German.)

True, some people, such as the famous philosopher A. A. Zinoviev, even today continue to assert: "If it were not for Stalin's brutal measures, we would not have been there in '41.

.

Expand full comment
Librarian's avatar

As an answer to Igz Navi: (Part one of two)

Stalin strikes against the "fifth column" in the 1930's

By the mid-1930s the Soviet leadership had largely accepted the notion and tried to convince the entire population of the country that the "enemies of the people" were operating with impunity in all Party, Soviet and economic organs and in the leadership of the (Trotskyite) Red Army. 2,300 words.

The struggle to clear the country of internal enemies became widespread in 1937. It was just as intense in 1938, and, according to the Stalinists, was prompted by the need to eliminate the "fifth column" in the face of an impending war. This was only partly true. At the same time, it was a struggle for the preservation of the Stalinist regime.

There is no doubt that the oppositionists, not only in the 20s, but for a good part of the 30s, WERE LOOKING FOR WAYS TO ELIMINATE STALIN AND HIS INNER CIRCLE.

However, "Stalin proved more cunning and resolute than his opponents, even though sometimes his power hung by a thread" (A. V. Shubin). The most notorious of the trials conducted in 1938. was the case of the "Right-Trotskyist anti-Soviet bloc". It began on March 2 in the October Hall of the House of Unions. There were 21 people in the dock.

Three of them were members of the Leninist Politburo - N. I. Bukharin, A. I. Rykov, and N. N. Krestinsky. Another former member of this cohort, M. P. Tomsky, was released from the fate of the defendant by his own suicide on August 22, 1936, on the eve of his arrest. Among the defendants were also former high-ranking officials of the central state and party apparatus - the People's Commissars for Foreign Trade, A. P. Rosengoltz, of the timber industry, V.I. Ivanov, Agriculture, M. A. Chernov, Finance, G. F. Grinko, Internal Affairs, G. G. Yagoda, and I. A. Zelensky, chairman of the Central Union.

A number of former first persons in the leadership of the Union republics were also on trial: Chairman of the Sovnarkom, People's Commissar for Foreign Affairs of Ukraine, X. G. Rakovsky, First Secretary of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Belarus V. F. Sharangovich, chairman of the Sovnarkom of the Uzbek SSR F. Khojaev, first secretary of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Uzbekistan A. I. Ikramov. Added to these main political defendants were several former employees of lesser rank: an adviser to the Soviet trade mission in Berlin, a secretary of the NKVD, Deputy People's Commissar of Agriculture, former secretaries of Yagoda, Kuibyshev and M. Gorky, and three well-known doctors.

In the indictment, it was stated that the defendants, "being implacable enemies of the Soviet power, in 1932-1933. On the instructions of the intelligence services of foreign countries hostile to the Soviet Union, they organized a conspiratorial group called the 'Right-Trotskyist Bloc', which united the underground anti-Soviet groups of Trotskyists, Rightists, Zinovievites, Mensheviks, SRs and bourgeois nationalists of Ukraine, Belarus, Georgia, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Central Asian republics. The "Right Trotskyist Bloc" aimed to overthrow the socialist social and state system existing in the USSR, to restore capitalism and the power of the bourgeoisie in the USSR through subversive, sabotage, terrorist, espionage and treasonous activities aimed at undermining the economic and defense power of the Soviet

The defendants were also accused of other crimes - committing a number of acts of sabotage to reduce and spoil crops; reducing the number of horses and cattle; artificially spreading an epizootic, as a result of which in Eastern Siberia alone in 1936 about 25,000 horses died; financing of Trotsky; preparation of bandit-insurgent kulak cadres to organize armed actions in the rear of the Red Army to begin an intervention against the USSR; creation of a terrorist group to prepare and carry out terrorist acts against Stalin, Molotov, Kaganovich and Voroshilov; personal attempt to commit terrorist acts against Stalin; assassination of Kirov, the death of M. Kuchma.

Gorky and his son, as well as Kuibyshev, Menzhinsky; instructed to commit an act of terrorism against Yezhov. The verdict also states that in 1918 Bukharin and his accomplices set out to kill Lenin, Stalin and Sverdlov; to form a new government of Bukharinists, Trotskyists and leftist Social Revolutionaries; and the attempt on Lenin's life on August 30, 1918 was the direct result of the plans of "leftist" communists led by Bukharin.

On March 13, 1938, the Military Collegium of the USSR Supreme Court announced the verdict. It turned out to be fatal for 18 out of 21 defendants. As a result of this and similar judicial and extrajudicial reprisals, a significant part of the old Bolshevik guards and many representatives of the Party and state apparatus, who were suspected of disloyalty and unfitness, were physically liquidated. In 1938 the Chekist actions on "national operations" were completed.

According to the archival sources in 1937 - 1938 the total number of repressed on these operations was 335,513 persons from whom

247,157 (73.6%) were sentenced to execution.

Professional revolutionaries who moved from the neighboring countries to the territory of the USSR were also put on trial. In January 1938, the Politburo of the Central Committee adopted a special decision - to shoot all the arrested renegades if they crossed the border "with a hostile purpose" and to impose a 10-year imprisonment sentence if no such purpose was found.

Repressions based on nationality did not bypass the law enforcement agencies either. On June 24, 1938 the directive of People's Commissar of Defense was issued, according to which the military men of all "nationalities, not making part of the Soviet Union" were to be dismissed from the army. Those who were born abroad and had relatives there were discharged first of all. According to the incomplete information, the special departments revealed 13,000 of "nationals" which had to be dismissed. In May 1938, the UK Party instructed to remove from the NKVD organs, (People's Commissariat for Internal Affairs), all employees who had relatives abroad and were from the "petty-bourgeoisie.

The number of Jews (went from 21.3% at the beginning of September 1938 to 3.5% by the end of 1939) significantly decreased. Totally, only during the years of the "Yezhevshina" 14 thousand were "purged" from the NKVD. This number includes 2,273 KGB officers, arrested in the period from I October 1936 to 15 August 1938. The Soviet regime's "counter-revolutionary crimes," of which 1,862 Chekists were repressed for counter-revolutionary crimes.

After the arrest of Yezhov (April 10, 1939) there were repressed 101 of the higher officials of the NKVD - not only the deputy commissar, but almost all of the heads of departments of the central apparatus of the NKVD, the Commissars of Internal Affairs of Union and autonomous republics; the heads of many regional, provincial and city departments of the NKVD.

According to the directory "Who led the NKVD. 1934-1941" (Moscow, 2002), a total of 22,168 OGPU-NKVD officers were repressed in 1933-1939. This number, along with security workers, includes and constitutes the vast majority of police officers, firefighters, employees of the NKVD troops, the Gulag system, civil registry, etc.

.

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts